Click on the Bristol Grammar School crest to visit our main School Website

Home | Welcome | Shortlist | BGS Reviews | Contact us

What I Was

Reviewed by Phoebe Allemenou


The central character in the book is flung into his third boarding school, 1960s' school called St Oswald's, where he has no clear talents, isn’t involved in sports, and has no real friends. His name, Hilary, isn’t known until about two-thirds of the way into the book, and his life is also pieced together in a random way, with no clear direction; and he doesn’t really care. While at St Oswald's, he meets Finn. He completely falls for his free lifestyle in a hut by the sea, and spends as long as he can there. As I was reading this book, I had read some other reviews for it which completely gave away the plot, so although I vaguely knew what was going to happen, it didn’t shock or interest me much.

The story took place over quite a long period, but so gradually that it didn’t make it seem very interesting. It was very slow moving, and it did pick up a bit along the way, but not a lot. I liked the ending, which contrasted with the rest of the story, but didn’t contradict it, and it gave it a new slant. The characters were very believable and the emotions were well shown through Meg Rosoff’s words. The detail was excellent and it was very well-written, but the plot itself didn’t hold much appeal for me.

I wouldn’t recommend it, because I found it hard to get into and I wasn’t as gripped as I found I was with other books, yet I know that others will recommend it because it was so well-written.