Click on the Bristol Grammar School crest to visit our main School Website

Home | Welcome | Shortlist | BGS Reviews | Contact us

Just in Case

Reviewed by Rory More-O'Ferrall


David Case believes fate is out to get him. When he sees his 18 month-old little brother about to jump out of the window, he thinks, “What if I looked two seconds later?” His little brother would have been dead. In an attempt to escape from Fate, David changes his clothes, makes new friends (Agnes and Peter), creates an imaginary pet dog, Boy, and even changes his name to Justin. But will all this help him in his vain attempt to get away?

Justin is an isolated teenager who is depressed, mad … what else can I say? Although she has portrayed the story line well, I think that I think Meg Rosoff takes the fate idea too far and in the end you sense she is writing about this depressed teenage boy for the fun of it, not to make a constructive novel. Maybe I am being a bit harsh as there is the occasional spellbinding page. One or two loose ends is no bad thing at the end of a book but in my opinion at the end of this novel there are too many paths that have landed up in the middle of nowhere.

I would praise Meg for her imagination and the most original book I have read in a while; and to make it onto a Carnegie shortlist is an amazing achievement in itself. But somehow I doubt Just In Case will go on to win. I rate this book 5.5/10.