Click on the Bristol Grammar School crest to visit our main School Website

Home | Welcome | Shortlist | BGS Reviews | Contact us

The Scarecrow and his Servant

Reviewed by Stephanie Francis


Finally he stopped, and looked at Jack. It was astonishing how much expression he could manage with his gash-mouth and stone-eyes.

‘Young man,’ he said, ‘I have a proposition to make. Here you are, an honest and willing youth, and here am I, a Scarecrow of enterprise and talent. What would you say if I offered you the position of my personal servant?’

I think this book is really easy-going, and you can put it down or pick it up at any time you like. It proved to be very light hearted and enjoyable. The characters were unique and easily recognisable and had their individual roles. I found it extremely simple and a bit predictable, very similar to a fairy tale. Consequently I feel as though it’s a book aimed at young children and the illustrations helped the reader to visualise a very good image in their head so I don’t feel it suits an older age-group. The front cover has a scene representing the main structure of the story. It shows a scene which includes the scarecrow and the servant walking along the green hills of spring Valley where his quest begins.

It’s a very different style for Philip Pullman and I feel as though it lets his reputation of a good standard of writing down. However it shows he is able to write books for many different age-groups and they are all very well loved.

Overall I enjoyed reading and acknowledging the adventures that came to mind and made me imagine that I was in the book myself. I felt this book wasn’t of a very high standard and I would very surprised if it won the Carnegie Award.